Sonic Frontiers Review: An Open-Zone Adventure

Explore a detailed review of Sonic Frontiers, covering its open-world design, gameplay mechanics, story, and overall reception since its 2022 release.

A New Direction for Sonic

Sonic Frontiers, released in 2022, represents a significant departure for the Sonic the Hedgehog series, introducing an “open-zone” gameplay concept. This shift moves away from traditional linear stages, offering vast landscapes for exploration and greater freedom for Sonic. The game embraces an “all-you-can-eat buffet” approach, constantly introducing new ideas and activities throughout its estimated 20-hour campaign. While some of these ideas may not always land perfectly, the sheer variety generally keeps the experience engaging and prevents boredom.

This reimagining places Sonic Frontiers among other classic series that have transitioned to open-world sandboxes, such as Pokémon Legends: Arceus and Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain. It aims to retain core elements that define the Sonic series while incorporating large explorable areas filled with diverse distractions and novel concepts. This blend of familiar Sonic elements with an open-world structure is largely considered a promising first attempt at blazing a new trail for the franchise.

Gameplay and Mechanics

Sprinting through the sprawling open-world areas, specifically the chain of five Starfall Islands, is a highlight of Sonic Frontiers. These islands serve as expansive playgrounds designed to test Sonic’s speed, though players should be wary of instantly fatal water or lava hazards. A standout new ability is the Cyloop, which allows Sonic to draw a circle while moving at high speed, creating a damaging tornado that affects everything within its radius. This versatile move can be used in combat, to solve puzzles, and even to generate rings, making it a consistently entertaining and useful mechanic.

The game offers a wide array of activities. Players might find themselves juggling robots in combat, attempting to beat time trials in 2D platforming stages, or even playing pinball inside a volcano. Other activities include grinding on epic rails, solving simple puzzles, engaging in puzzle-platforming, and fishing. This variety ensures that even if not all activities are equally polished, the overall experience benefits from the diverse offerings. One notable element that breaks up the open world is the Cyber Space levels. These are bite-sized, linear Sonic levels focused on racing against the clock and collecting rings to reach the goal, providing a contrast to the open-zone exploration.

However, not all mechanics are universally praised. The default starting speed of Sonic, unless boosted by a maximum ring count, is sometimes perceived as slower than desired, though it can be improved by leveling up the speed stat. Combat, in particular, has been noted as a weaker aspect, often devolving into button-mashing for simple combos against robotic enemies. Additionally, an “absurd amount of pop-in” is frequently observed, especially when Sonic is moving at high speeds. Some critics also point to “ancient gatekeeping grindy methods” that can disrupt the game’s flow.

Story and Characters

Sonic Frontiers weaves a narrative across its five Starfall Islands, uncovering the predictable backstory of a long-extinct race. Familiar characters like Amy and Knuckles make appearances, alongside a new enigmatic enemy named Sage, whose story unfolds slowly through vague dialogue. The various plot threads, while sometimes feeling disconnected and relying on clichĂ©s about friendship and ancient technology, do create opportunities for strong character development. The game features some of the most in-depth characterizations seen in the series, including a focus on the rivalry between Sonic and Knuckles, and building Tails’ role beyond just being Sonic’s sidekick.

The story is generally described as surprisingly well-founded and clean of “annoying 3rd tier friends,” offering a deeper narrative without being unnecessarily edgy. Sage, in particular, has been highlighted as a memorable new character, with hopes for her future inclusion in the series.

Critical Reception and Overall Experience

Sonic Frontiers has received a “Mixed or Average” critical reception on Metacritic, with a Metascore of 70 based on 90 critic reviews for the PlayStation 5 version. User scores, however, are “Generally Favorable,” averaging 8.1 from nearly 4,000 ratings.

Many reviewers acknowledge that while the game is far from perfect, it represents a significant step forward for 3D Sonic gameplay, with some calling it the best 3D Sonic game in years or even the best since Sonic Adventure. The ambition of Sonic Team and Sega in creating this new experience is frequently highlighted. The game is praised for its “wonderfully melancholic world” and “highly entertaining adventure.” The overall consensus often points to a “wonderfully built base” for future games, despite execution issues like the aforementioned pop-in and occasional grindy elements. The game’s vision is considered “absolutely fabulous,” even if the execution sometimes falls short. Some user reviews praise the game’s epic scenes, incredible soundtrack, and engaging boss fights, while acknowledging issues like an empty open-world map and short, sometimes unnecessary Cyber Space levels.

FAQ

What is the main gameplay style of Sonic Frontiers? Sonic Frontiers features an “open-zone” gameplay style, which is a new direction for the series, offering large explorable areas rather than strictly linear levels.

How long is the main campaign of Sonic Frontiers? The main campaign of Sonic Frontiers is estimated to be around 20 hours long.

What new ability does Sonic gain in Frontiers? Sonic gains the Cyloop ability, allowing him to create a damaging tornado by drawing a circle while moving at high speed, useful for combat, puzzles, and collecting rings.

Are there traditional linear Sonic levels in the game? Yes, the game includes “Cyber Space levels” which are bite-sized, linear stages designed for speed and ring collection, breaking up the open-world exploration.

What is the critical reception of Sonic Frontiers? Sonic Frontiers received a “Mixed or Average” critical reception with a Metascore of 70, but generally favorable user reviews, often praised as a promising new direction for the series despite some flaws.